On a whim, I've started re-watching the X-Files on Netflix, an episode here and there. It's one of those shows that was around during high school that I watched in chunks, but never religiously (like Buffy). I'm 5 episodes in and it is 90's as fuck. Not super-great or anything, but there's hints of awesomeness here and there. Also, the leads have a ton of chemistry right there from episode 1, so that helps.