Wound up getting the Supercharged Mini Coop. Love it so much. Needs a little TLC (it's 8-9 years old and has gone through multiple owners). Stuff like I need to replace the power port / cigarette lighter, get a new battery for the keyless fob, get one of the windows retinted (some dings in the tint).
Overall, feel like we got a great deal on it and am looking forward to keeping this one for a long, long time. :D